Saturday, 7 July 2012

Is the CPIB A Vampire (organisation)?

Singapore is slowly slipping into the Twilight zone. Consider the following story (imaginary of course). A certain Mr Caw retuns home from work and finds a man pinning his daughter down on the bed, ripping her panties off. What did he do? He decides to "monitor the situation". Because you know, until penetration occurs, it is technically not considered rape yet.

When the man had finished the deed, Mr Caw, never one to jump to conclusions asked: "What are you doing to my daughter?" To which the man replied: "I'm deflowering her to get her started on the next phase of her life as a woman". On hearing that Mr Caw replied: "Oh I see. I'm okay with that!"

In the recent NParks bicycle tender controversy, the Singaporean public had been similarly raped, financially speaking. And Mr Khaw, the Minister of National Development was okay with it too.

If a writer to the forum in the paper yesterday is accurate, then it would appear there is a distinct likelyhood that the tender document for the bicycles had been specified with a particular brand of bicycle and possibly a particular supplier already in mind.

I should think there is sufficient prima facie evidence for the CPIB to step in and conduct a thorough investigation for fraud prejudicial to the public's interest in this tender. What are they waiting for? Does the CPIB actually need someone to file an official complaint to initiate an investigation? You know, like a vampire needs to be invited into the house first or it cannot cross the threshold?

And while they are at it, they should look into the conduct of previous tenders and contracts awarded by NParks. As the saying goes: There is seldom only one cockroach... They might want to call on Ms Nora Samosir to assist :)

In giving a free pass to NParks in this matter, Mr Khaw has not thought deeply enough on the consequences of his action. Far from ensuring that such lapses in tendering do not occur again, it actually sets a precedence for others to follow. The reasoning being if NParks can get away with it, why can't I?

From the multitude of recent cases of misconduct by senior civil servants (sexual favours in return for contracts for example), I would say that the quality of the people in the civil service is deteriorating. Something is not working correctly in the hiring and/or promotion process.

These lapses may be minor on their own, but collectively they are undermining the public's perception of the quality of the civil service. And like termite infested wood looking good on the outside but is rotten within, it will one day contribute to the collapse of the government.

One hopes that someone if not from the government then definitely from the pposition will file a query in the coming parliamentary session to address this issue and pursue it until it is properly concluded.



Thursday, 5 July 2012

"Killing and Eating of Chickens is Highly Unlikely" says Fox Guarding Hen House

In the midst of the libor interest rate rigging scandal that broke out recently, ABS (Association of Banks Singapore) director, Mrs Ong-Ang Ai Boon says that the rigging
of Sibor (set by ABS) "is highly unlikely". In all things and especially those things related to financial matters, the maxim: "Trust but verify" is increasingly
a MUST.

The fact that the only a small pool of players are involved in setting the Sibor is NOT a safeguard against malfeasance. If anything, it facilitates collusion in rigging activity as all players will be well known to each other and familiarity breeds, in this case, mischief. At a minimum, alarms should be flashing for anti-competitive behaviour.

Saying that the incentive to rig the Sibor rate is low because of the "small size of Singapore's housing loan market" is being disingenuous at best. I don't think Mr Fox is going to turn up his nose at a chance of a chicken meal just because the hen is skinny! If so, why did the banks lobby for the HDB housing loans to be liberalised? I believe in the past, it was exclusively a HDB business.

A good step to minimise the incentive to rig the Sibor rate is to ensure that banks that set the rate are not allowed to trade in any instruments that depend on the level that rate is set. Ie: their prop desk traders are verboten to trade in any such instruments in the market. The conflict of interest is just too great.

The other is of course to do a thorough audit of the banks to prove conclusively that no such illicit activity had occured. If it is as Mrs Ong-Ang had said, the affected banks should have no objections. As it is, I think some of the banks on the list are already guilty for rigging the libor rate.

Interestingly enough, only ABS responded to this issue and not MAS, the regulator. I'm sure MAS had similar faith that investment companies kept their hands off their client's segregated funds. But as the MF Global scandal showed, that faith is misplaced. Are you STILL sleeping MAS? While you are sleeping, our reputation as a well regulated financial centre is slipping down the drain...

But whatever, I'm sure Mr Khaw would be okay with it.

Dr Goh Keng Swee Should Pay Mr Khaw Boon Wan A Visit


Dr Goh Keng Swee famously chose to walk rather than take a cab to save money. Today, that ethos of thrift and prudent expenditure is but only a distant memory it seems. More details of NParks spendthrift ways came to light in today's report of their purchase of bicycles costing S$2200 apiece for their staff.

Apparently NParks approved the purchase because only one tender submission was received. And Mr Khaw was satisfied with that reason! Has neither Mr Khaw or NParks heard of the concept of a failed tender? Bicycles are not such an exotic product that there is only one supplier available. The correct procedure would have been to call for a re-tender and making sure that at least several potential suppliers are directly informed of the tender.

NParks had given the excuse that a foldable bike would eliminate the need for a van to transport the bikes and staff on their rounds. Are we to understand that with a foldable bike, staff would transport themselves and the bike? How so?

This is an example of when heads should roll. Someone should be fired for mishandling this tender. What next? The traffic police tender for patrol cars has only one tender response proposing the Buggatti Veyron for several million dollars a piece and it will be approved? Because you know, with the proliferation of Ferrari cars and the now updated need to tougher on traffic violation by such vehicles, the police need faster cars to keep up? Really?

PM Lee, you have a problem. One of your ministers has a tendency of not only shooting himself in the foot, his stray shots will start hitting yours as well. From prioritizing "protecting our babies" from wild boar attacks instead of focusing on upgrading the standard of their education to saying that HDB flats have not shrunk in size and now his acceptance of an obviously flawed purchasing decision, his is not only a deadweight your administration is dragging around, but it is actually pulling it in the opposite direction.

The PAP might have a mole in the WP. but you have in your cabinet a minister who could not have done a better job of sabotaging its credibility than if he had been planted there by the opposition. I do not see WHY the public should continue to fund his million plus salary till the next GE when it could be better spend on someone else more competent. Surely you can find someone else more suitable in the 80 plus other MPs in your party.

This minister is likely unelectable. As PM, you need to exercise your leadership role and do the right thing. Far be it for me to tell you what needs to be done and to who but to maintain the status quo would endanger your and the rest of the governments already shaky standing with the electorate.

Tuesday, 26 June 2012

In Two Minds

Inconsistent, conflicting and contradictory. These are not words you would want to use when discussing the policies of the your government or leaders. Consider the report in yesterday's paper about "Bigger, breezier hawker centre for Bedok". Stalls will increase from 6 to 13 sq meters while the roof will be built higher to improve air flow.

Yet when residents of Bishan complained that a new elderly care centre built on an open space near their apartments would block their view and be too cramped , ie: reduce air flow and light, their protestations basically fell on deaf ears. Dr Amy Khor almost choked out the reason on TalkingPoint (on ChannelNewsAsia) and I quote: "...due to constraints of SCARCITY of land", there is apparently no other choice but for those Bishan residents to bear with it. (I would suggest that they excavate a cavern underground and built the eldercare centre there, below ground!)

SO, the government ACTUALLY recognises that bigger and breezier is BETTER and is prepared to trumpet it when it suits them and earn them brownie points, otherwise why didn't they build the new hawker centre shoebox style? People spend at most an hour at a hawker centre for their meals, but they spend most of their lives in their apartments. A cramped stuffy hawker centre is an inconvenience people are prepared to bear, but an eldercare centre stuffed right in their faces is something they have to endure 24/7.

Mr Khaw Boon Wan, had the chutzpah to say that HDB flats have NOT shrunk over the years. But it turns out that this is only partially correct if non-usable areas (like aircon ledges etc) are included in the floor space. A 'trick' that his own ministry is supposed to regulate real estate companies from abusing. With regards to shoebox apartments, he is just going to "monitor the situation". We are not sure what he means by that.

When Resorts World Sentosa decided to test the limits of what it can do to attract Singaporeans to its (let's be honest here) casinos by providing free bus shuttles, Dr Vivian Balakrishnan, the Minister then in charge didn't say he would "monitor the situation". He ordered the free shuttles stopped immediately. Compared to free bus shuttles, the damage caused by a need to reverse course on shoebox apartments is considerably higher. And Mr Khaw is dittering. He is unsure just which constituency he is representing: rich real estate developers looking to squeeze every last drop of profit or citizens of Singapore who will have to live in or put up with wastage of a precious resource: land, built with buildings not fit for purpose, "inhuman" as soon-to-be ex-CEO of Capitaland, Mr Liew Mun Leong put it.

Strangely enough, when it comes to culling wild boars, Mr Khaw is surprisingly decisive. He is prepared to rely on the flimsiest of trumped up reasons: "protect our babies" with apparently no need for further "monitoring" to essentially visit mass murder on innocent boars. Karma has its ways of evening things out in the
end. Who knows, Mr Khaw himself may come back as one :)

The government has employed every trick in the book when it suits its purposes:
The elderly (when building care centers without regard to existing residents and structures. I mean how can anyone argue against it? Can anyone be so hard hearted and inconsiderate to deny our elderly? Babies. This latest one from our Mr Khaw. Everyone loves babies! Yes lets kill the wild boars just in case a mere look from one will harm an innocent child. We wonder what the government will next use: Widows? Orphans?

So which is it? Big, breezy and spacious good or bad? The government can't have it both ways. When you lie and put forward courses of action that are so contrary to common sense, sooner rather than later, you will trip up and contradict yourself. And this is what we are seeing. While the government may be in two minds (saying and doing contradictory things, whenever it suits them), the electorate is increasingly aware that the government is not always acting in their interests and in this, they are of one mind.

Saturday, 23 June 2012

Are You Sleeping? Are You Sleeping, MAS?

Mr Bob Yap, a liquidator for MF Global Singapore made an interesting reply in the forum page in the Straits Times on Friday regarding a query posed by a former client of MF Global Singapore. To wit: "We were told that our funds were kept in Singapore in segregated accounts, so why is my money in Australia?"

Apparently, for clients trading in CFDs (Contracts for Difference), such funds for their margin accounts were supposed to be kept in Australia where the counter party for such trades is based. This brings up many questions.

1. Is the client in question, Mr Vernon Khoo trading in CFDs?
2. If so, why isn't Mr Vernon Khoo aware of this? Another case of mis-selling like in the Lehman case?
3. What about clients who trade more than CFDs? How does MF Global decide how to apportion their client's margin funds to be kept separately in Singapore and Australia?
4. Are segregated client funds in Australia treated any differently from those in Singapore?

With regards to question (4), if the protection afforded to client segregated funds in Australia is less than that afforded to their funds in Singapore, then it represents a loophole in the protection a client might reasonably expect to have. Is MAS aware of this?

In any case, the creditors of MF Global, whether in Singapore or Australia do not have any rights to client funds. They may only recover any outstanding debt from MF Global's OWN assets. So it is surprising that it is taking such a long time to resolve. Who is paying for the services of liquidators like Mr Bob Yap?

More importantly, in this whole saga, MAS has not come out to clarify the terms of segregated client funds. Is MF Global the ONLY company that has been making free with its clients funds? What about the other investment/finance/brokerage companies? Is MAS cracking down on them to ensure that what happened to MF Global's clients do not happen to clients of other such firms?

I think the can of worms is so BIG that MAS doesn't know how to handle it. Such financial chicanery/shenanigans is so deeply embedded in the fabric of how these financial firms do business that if MAS were to crack down on it, our vaunted status as a significant player in the field will wither as all the major players will leave.

We've used the lure of our CPF funds to kick start our financial industry. Unfortunately for Singaporeans, when Mr Goh Chok Tong promised a Swiss standard of living for us, he didn't clarify that it was only for the bankers. When it comes down to it, (so far at least), MAS appears to prefer to let Singaporean investors be screwed rather than to do the right thing.

Wild Boars Attacked by Minister Khaw

Day by day, incident by incident, the credibility of the government sinks ever lower. Two wild boars wandered into Bishan-Ang Mo Kio park and apparently charged at a security guard and a child. A perfect cover and EXCUSE to justify an already desired government action.

Wild boars bad right? Actually this is what is called being economical with the truth. We are not told WHY the wild boar charged. What did the security guard do? Was he just standing there silently? Or did he more likely try to scare the animal away by shouting at it, or even throwing sticks or stones at it?

Faced with an aggressive human, the wild boar was within its rights to charge at the security guard since it was being harassed. The security guard likely moved away to avoid the boar and the child was unfortunately in the wrong place at the wrong time and was targeted by the boar instead (as another human). That the child's life was endangered was likely due to the actions of the security guard. This is more likely the more complete version of what happened.

"My priority is to protect our babies". Please Mr Khaw, what do you take us Singaporeans for? Idiots? Using potential dangers to babies to justify culling the boars? Unprovoked, the tendency for wild boars is to flee from humans. They have been living for years in Singapore. If they have a natural instinct to hurt humans, they would have done so many times in the past and there would have been numerous such incidents. You might want to ask the "two university professors" if humans are a natural target for wild boars. I can tell you the answer is no.

Since Mr Khaw is SO concerned about the safety of our babies, perhaps his ministry should make it compulsory that all windows in highrise apartments be permanently sealed shut. Quite a few children have fallen out of them when left unattended. It will also save quite a few maids from toppling out as well when they clean the windows or hang out the washing. How about that, Mr Khaw?

Actually, Mr Khaw, your ministry is directly responsible for this incident. You are destroying our ever shrinking wild and green spaces, the habitat of the wild boars, to build more and more HDB flats, private condos etc to house more and more foreigners. By reducing their habitat, you are forcing their population densities to go up in the remaining green areas and when the population pressures get too high, they spill out into our parks. Can we blame them?

No, we blame you, first for not speaking up and standing up to your cabinet colleagues on their flawed economic growth strategy based on ever increasing imports of foreign workers and secondly, for building ever more housing on our remaining green areas. It is the human population that needs managing. Killing off every single last wild boar would not solve our housing/elderly/jobs situation.

Singaporeans got attacked by greedy shoebox apartment developers and Minister Khaw says: "I'll monitor the situation." CEO of CapitaLand says shoebox apartments are "inhuman" and several weeks later, steps down, apparently to pursue personal interests. A likely provoked wild boar charges some humans and it's: We've got to kill them! Wow...so decisive! Yes, it may be necessary to reduce the size of the wild boar population, but please, don't use "protecting our babies" as justification. That's just insulting!

In the meantime, the Gardens by the Bay is opening. I don't think there are any wild gingers or seeds of primary forest trees there to destroy. Why don't we relocate some wild boar there? It will help to attract more visitors!




Sunday, 17 June 2012

Why Ferrari Owners Have To Be Culled

Their population is surging. These is due to our open door policy for anyone with money. Witness the recent addition of Eduardo Saverin and Nathan Tinkler for example. (These are the people who can afford such cars).

They are a threat to public safety. Witness the recent case of the Ferrari driver running the red light at a traffic junction by a Chinese PR which resulted in multiple casualties. Together with apparently double standards when it comes to enforcement of road safety regulations by the traffic police towards owners of such cars, public safety is doubly jeopardised.

They destroy forests. Okay, Ferrari owners are only partly to be blamed for this. But basically rising ownership of private vehicles is causing traffic congestion and results in more of our green spaces being destroyed to build more roads. Bukit Brown anyone?

This is obviously a tongue-in-cheek response to the recent decision by the authorities to cull the wild boar population in Singapore. Note that wild boars have yet to threaten much less hurt anyone. And we already want to kill them just in case. How many people are killed by cars on our roads? Yet, no one has called for a ban or reduction in car numbers.

Yes, they may trample undergrowth, eat seeds and wild ginger. Their impact on forest regeneration is negligible compared to the size of forest land that we destroy to build housing for people that the government wants to import in ever increasing numbers. When such land is cleared, what do you think happens to all the seeds and wild ginger? I think a reduction in human population will have a far larger positive impact on reducing damage to our environment.

We may unfortunately have to do some level of culling eventually. If so, we need to ensure that it doesn't degenerate into the kind of 'scientific' culling like that done by Japanese 'scientists'/whalers where the meat ends up being sold in the market. I would suggest that any culled boars only be given to the zoo to supplement the diet of predatory animals like the tigers and leopards.

In the meantime, it still amazes me how quick the authorities can move on issues when it suits them and their agenda. Witness what happened to the hobby farmer on former KTM railway land in Clementi. Behaviour of this sort that we used to associate with lesser governments in other countries (which will diplomatically remain unnamed). Or the recent Woffles Wu speeding case...